A mattress is a big investment that will hopefully deliver several years of comfortable sleep. Unfortunately, many mattresses aren’t as comfortable as one would hope and most will gradually lose their ability to deliver maximum comfort and support over time. Toppers are designed with comfort features such as memory foam that allow you to vary the softness to fit your particular needs. Some toppers are even designed to provide a cooling effect through increased firmness or improved air flow. This will usually lead to better sleep for those who have a tendency to become overheated at night.

Also, the addition of a mattress protector or encasement to your bed is an important step in preventing stains and will make the cleaning process so much easier since most toppers costing over $100 come with a cover that can be removed for washing and drying. Purchasing a topper that is under $100 might mean that you will need to buy a separate cover if you want to guard against spills and other stain causing activities.

Today, we’ll take a look at the best mattress topper based on features and price.


Best Mattress Topper: $100 – $200

The $100 – $200 range for mattress toppers tends to be the high end for toppers and typically consists of the 3 – 4 inch multi-layered memory foam and cooling gel products that provide superior comfort and support compared to lower priced toppers. Multi-layered products generally have a fluffy top that rests over a couple inches of cooling gel memory foam or high density foam that adapts to your body type to reduce tossing and turning. In addition, most covers can be removed so that they can be washed and dried. These toppers usually work well for all types of sleepers including back, stomach, and side sleepers.

When selecting the best mattress topper for you, it’s important to decide how thick you want the topper to be, if you want a single or multi-layered product, and whether or not the cooling gel memory foam is important. Your decisions will likely depend on how soft you need your bed to be and whether or not you become overheated at night. Aside from those features, you may want to consider the warranty that is offered and, of course, how much you are willing to spend. In general, most people want the multi-layered toppers that have the cooling gel foam, but there are some great single layer options that lack the cooling gel foam and will save you some money.

As you move down in price, the toppers will typically lose thickness as well as the multi-layer and cooling gel features. While this is a deal breaker for most people, you may not want or need the extra features that restless sleepers require for a good night’s sleep. The most important step is identifying your own individual needs before making a purchase.

Below, you’ll find our top 3 picks in the $100 – $200 price range…

Sleep Innovations 4-Inch Dual Layer Mattress Topper

This is a two-layer mattress topper that has a 2 Inch base layer made up of cooling gel memory foam that is firm yet plush which allows it to conform to your body while relieving pressure points. The top layer is a 2 Inch fiber-fill layer contained within a quilted cover that has a convenient edge that stretches to fit snug around the edge of your bed to keep the top layer in place. The top layer provides a very soft feel that many people want on their bed while the bottom memory foam layer adapts to provide maximum comfort and support.

The manufacturer states that using this topper is like sleeping on a cloud which we would agree with. It works very well for those who are on the heavier side and seems comfortable for all types of sleepers including back, side, and stomach sleepers.

Out of the box, it has only a slight scent if any at all and that will usually dissipate after a couple of days. It also might seem a bit small for your bed at first, but it should expand to fit the bed nicely once you’ve used it a time or two. Size options range from twin all the way up to a California King. Although the gel memory foam layer is not designed for washing and drying, the top fiber-fill layer has a cover that can be removed for easy cleaning.

While this mattress topper is clearly one of the best available, individuals who do not like an overly soft bed may not appreciate the top fiber-fill layer. Although there are cheaper topper options out there, we feel that the adage ‘you get what you pay for’ applies here and we would go with this topper over the alternatives.

Best Price Mattress 4-Inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Like the Sleep Innovations topper, this is a dual layer product, but the top layer is 1.5 Inches of memory foam while the bottom layer is 2.5 Inches of high density foam. The memory foam topper is designed to adapt to your body and relieve pressure points to give you a better night’s sleep. The manufacturer also points out that it works to reduce motion transfer from your partner through responsive active suspension so that your sleep remains uninterrupted. Those looking to make their bed firmer might find this topper to be softer than they would prefer.

This topper has also been shown to provide great comfort for larger individuals and those who sleep on their back, stomach, or side. It seems to hold up well over time and helps reduce sleep discomfort for those with a history of aches, pains, or joint problems. Its ability to provide maximum comfort is mostly due to the conforming action of the memory foam.

Out of the box, you might notice a little bit of a scent, but that should go away after a few days. It will start to expand once it is removed from its packaging and should continue to grow in size until it is roughly as big as your bed. It may not fully expand until you have used it a few times. Size options are available from twin all the way up to California King.

While we prefer the Sleep Innovations topper, this alternative is a great option for those who do not want the very soft feel of the fiber-fill top or who are looking to spend less money. It also comes with a cover that can be removed for washing and drying which is something you do not get with many of the toppers priced under $100. It has a 5 year manufacturer warranty which is half as long as the Sleep Innovations warranty, but this may be a nonissue for those who are more concerned with spending less.

LUCID 3-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Unlike the Sleep Innovations and Best Price Mattress toppers, this option is a single layer of memory foam that contains a cooling gel material that is supposed to help reduce heat while you sleep. Like the other options discussed above, this topper is soft to the touch and conforms to your body in order to provide maximum comfort and support. It has a ventilated design that is said to improve airflow.

The topper will begin expanding when removed from its packaging and should conform to the size of your bed after a couple days of use. This topper is cheaper than the two discussed above, but is also thinner and does not come with a cover. Most people choose to purchase a protective cover or encasement separately in order to guard against stains. This will add some additional cost.

In addition, this topper has only a 3 year warranty compared to the 5 year warranty of the Best Price Mattress topper and the 10 year warranty of the Sleep Innovations topper. For those who care about extended warranties, the additional cost for the first two toppers might be worth it for the longer warranty coupled with the thicker material and additional features. Ultimately, the LUCID topper is a pretty good option for those who want to spend less and who want a basic topper with no frills attached.

Exceptional Sheets Extra Plush Cooling Topper

Not everyone is looking for a topper that contains memory foam and some people simply want something that can provide an extra layer of support while maintaining a high level of softness without conforming to your body. The Exceptional Sheets topper contains a down alternative that feels similar to down without the feathers. It also comes with a fitted skirt that allows you to secure it to any mattress that is less than 18 Inches deep. This means that you could even use it over a memory foam topper if you want to get the additional comfort that memory foam offers without sinking into the foam.

Although this topper is slightly more expensive than others, it does seem to be higher quality. It’s also designed with baffle box stitching to ensure that the filling remains evenly distributed with use. In addition, the fill weight for this topper tends to be higher than the cheaper options. A higher fill weight is important for some people because it helps the product hold up over a longer period of time and is great for use over a memory foam topper since it creates enough firmness to prevent the user from sinking into the foam. This also works to counterbalance the overheating that some people experience with certain mattresses and memory foam toppers that do not allow for much airflow.

Best Mattress Topper: Under $100

When you drop below the $100 price level for mattress toppers, most of the products contain a down alternative fiber that isn’t designed to conform to the body and; therefore, tends not to be as comfortable as the more expensive toppers. These toppers are ideal for individuals who sleep reasonably well without a topper and who are looking for something to provide an additional layer of softness as well as a barrier for dust mites and allergens. Having said that, there are still a couple of products available in this price range that contain a memory foam gel that you may want to consider looking at if you’re wanting a more comfortable topper that is budget friendly. If you are going to consider these lower priced memory foam toppers over the more expensive options then you just need to be aware that they typically aren’t as thick, some might not come with a removable cover for washing and drying, and they usually do not last as long or offer the same type of warranty.

Below, you’ll find a few good topper options under $100…

DreamFoam Bedding 2-Inch Gel Swirl Memory Foam Topper

Although this topper is about half as thick as the more expensive options, it is a great option for those who don’t want to spend over $100. This topper is only 2 Inches thick and; therefore, is probably not the best option for larger individuals or those who suffer from back or joint pain since it won’t provide as much cushion as the alternatives discussed above. It is constructed of memory foam material so it should adapt to your body in order to provide a high level of comfort while sleeping.

Out of the box, the DreamFoam topper does seem to have a stronger odor than the other toppers, but this should dissipate over time. You may want to consider letting it air out before using it if you’re sensitive to smells. It will be compressed when removed from the box, but will start to expand as soon as you remove the packaging and should grow to fit your bed over the course of a day or two. To keep the topper in place, you might want to consider placing a fitted bed sheet over it. This should prevent it from moving around too much.

While this topper doesn’t come with a cover and has only a 3 year warranty, it is very popular with those who want to spend under $100 and who don’t like the thicker toppers available. If you feel like you sink into the thicker toppers too much or have trouble turning because of the amount of memory foam material that the more expensive toppers have then the DreamFoam product might just be the solution for you.

Zinus Sleep Master 2-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Similar to the DreamFoam topper, this one is 2 Inches thick and constructed of memory foam material with added cooling gel. This product has a more uniform color than the swirl pattern used in the DreamFoam topper. The Zinus topper is soft and will conform to your body while you sleep to provide comfort and support. Again, the thinner 2 Inch toppers probably aren’t the best option if you’re a larger individual or you suffer from back and joint pain since these do not provide as much support as the 3 – 4 Inch alternatives.

As with most toppers, you may notice an odor with this one when you take it out of the box, but this should dissipate over time. If the odor is overwhelming you may want to let it air out before placing it on your bed. The topper will arrive compressed and rolled up into a box, but it will expand after it is removed from the packaging. If you’re having trouble keeping the topper in place, we recommend using a fitted sheet over it. You may also want to think about purchasing a cover or encasement to protect the topper from damage and spills.

LUCID 3-Inch Lavender Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper

If you’ve ever purchased a mattress topper that has a terrible odor then you’ll appreciate the soothing lavender infused scent of this LUCID mattress topper. Not only is this topper on the more affordable end of the spectrum, but it smells great (for awhile at least) and it’s thicker than most toppers in this price range. While most toppers under $100 are only 2 Inches thick, this topper is 3 Inches thick which provides increased comfort and support especially for larger individuals and those who suffer from back or joint pain. That being said, if you’re used to high density memory foam toppers then this product might disappoint since it isn’t as dense as higher priced toppers and you will likely find that you sink into the foam more than you would on a denser product.

Individuals who tend to become overheated at night might find that they dislike this topper since it is a bit thicker than most in this price range and doesn’t have the density required to keep you from sinking into the material. If overheating is a problem for you, we would recommend a thinner or denser topper. Those who don’t have a problem with overheating should be perfectly fine using this topper. In addition, the less dense products tend to make it harder to turn in bed and we would recommend a different product if you are the type of sleeper that likes to turn a lot during the night.

Similar to most other toppers, this one will arrive compressed and rolled into a box. It will begin to expand after being removed from the packaging and should reach its full size within a day or two. Most people find that they can start using the topper right away and are able to keep it from moving around by placing a fitted bed sheet over it. Since this topper does not come with a removable cover, you may want to consider purchasing a cover or encasement to protect it from damage and stains.

Balichun Fitted Quilted Mattress Topper

While many of the mattress toppers being sold today contain memory foam material, there are still some topper products that are manufactured using a down alternative that is specifically designed to deliver a soft and fluffy sleeping experience rather than adaptive support. These are particularly well-suited for people who sleep reasonably well already and who don’t need the pressure point or joint relief that pain sufferers require. They are also great if you have an older mattress that has lost much of its cushion and you are looking to restore some of that cushion rather than getting a new mattress. The Balichun is an affordable alternative down topper that has a fitted skirt that slides over the edge or your mattress to keep the topper in place.

Leisure Town Down Alternative Mattress Topper

This is another great option if you want a topper that is constructed of a down alternative rather than memory foam. It’s a soft topper that comes with deep pockets to secure it to your mattress. Again, the down alternative toppers are primarily for adding a soft extra layer of support to your bed without really conforming to your body to relieve pressure points or discomfort from back and joint pain. The baffle box stitching keeps the fiber filling evenly distributed and ensures a uniform level of comfort. This topper is particularly well-suited for those looking to soften up an overly firm bed or reduce the uncomfortable feeling of springs. Generally, the down alternative options aren’t as useful if you are a larger individual or are looking for something to provide adaptive comfort and support.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *